14. The Suitcase Killer

Rabbit Hole Happy Hour

Three suitcases filled with body parts were discovered washed ashore on Virginia Beach. The remains were identified by friends as 39 year old, Bill McGuire. As police interview Bill's friends they learn that he'd been missing for over 30 days, but his wife Melanie never reported it. Melanie tells investigators that Bill took off after an explosive argument and the two were going through a divorce. Despite this plausible story, Melanie becomes the center of the investigation which uncovers a laundry list of incriminating actions carried out by Melanie leading up to Bill's disappearance. But was she really the perpetrator? Some view the evidence as coincidence. You decide.