Ep. 33 Romper el Circulo (It Ends With Us) by Colleen Hoover vs. It Ends With Us (2024)

Books vs. Movies

Send us a text

Can a story about abuse be labeled a romance? Join me, Lluvia, as I traverse the controversial terrain of Colleen Hoover's novel "It Ends With Us" and its 2024 film adaptation featuring Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni. My initial hesitation to engage with this narrative transforms into a curiosity-driven exploration of its complex themes. We'll dissect Lily Blossom Bloom's turbulent relationships with Ryle Kincaid and Atlas Corrigan, scrutinizing how the film adaptation aligns with and diverges from the book's original story line. From the exclusion of Ellen DeGeneres diary entries to Lily’s entrepreneurial shift, each narrative choice paints a refreshed, yet faithful picture.
Together, we’ll question the portrayal of abuse in the story and its implications on perceptions of romance. Drawing parallels with narratives like "After We Collided," I present my perspective on whether Hoover's story glamorizes abusive relationships or offers a nuanced look into the protagonist Lily’s struggles. The film's flashbacks and streamlined plot provide a different lens through which to view Lily's world, emphasizing the emotional weight of her decision to break the cycle of abuse. These narrative choices, along with the altered character dynamics, invite us to reconsider how such stories impact audiences and challenge societal norms.
As I journey through the adaptations, I’ll tackle the tough question of whether certain relationships enable abuse or encourage growth. Alyssa's evolution in the movie compared to the book offers a fresh depth to the narrative, adding complexity to her role as Lily’s confidante. The emotional resonance of Lily's ultimate decision in the film stirs powerful audience reactions, underscoring the poignant theme of ending cycles of harm. This episode invites you to ponder your own views, share your thoughts, and join a community eager to explore the intricate worlds of books and their cinematic counterparts.

All episodes of the podcast can be found on our website: https://booksvsmovies.buzzsprout.com/share
Connect with me: Instagram | Threads | Bookshop | Goodreads | Blog

章

1. Book vs. Movie (00:00:00)

2. Twists and Changes in Adaptation (00:08:22)

3. Names, Relationships, and Differences (00:19:47)

4. Abusive Relationship and Enabler Roles (00:32:38)

5. Does It Glamorize Abuse? (00:45:02)

6. Impact of Abuse Story in Media (00:52:46)